Cuttyhunk Island boasts a charming array of limited yet delightful food options, each brimming with character and flavor. Whether you’re seeking a quick and satisfying bite or a leisurely culinary experience, the island caters to a range of tastes. From Soprano’s Pizza, where gourmet brick oven pizza meets seafood specials in a scenic outdoor setting, to the inviting Cuttyhunk Cafe, offering freshly brewed coffee and delectable pastries, there’s an option for every mood. Visit the fishing dock to indulge in the simplicity of a lobster roll at the Lobster Shack or savor the catch of the day from the Raw Bar. While the dining options on Cuttyhunk Island may be limited, they certainly don’t fall short in delivering delicious cuisine that captures the island’s essence.
Many places accept credit card or digital payment but a few still require cash.
Cuttyhunk is a dry island so you wont find anywhere that sells beer, wine or liquor. Make sure you plan accordingly for your trip.
Cuttyhunk Restaurants
Back Door Burrito
A small selection of burritos and bowls open on the weekends
Back Door Burritos offers chicken or beef burritos and bowls behind the the Island Market. You can find their pop up stand on Friday and Saturday evenings throughout the season from 6:00-7:30pm.
They only accept cash so make sure you have some on hand!
Cuttyhunk Cafe
Grab-and-go breakfast at the fishing dock
The Cuttyhunk Cafe is a cozy island haven offering more than just great coffee – it’s a gathering spot. With fresh coffee and delectable food, this charming cafe invites you to unwind while savoring a taste of Cuttyhunk’s tranquility. Whether you’re seeking a peaceful morning retreat or a casual afternoon chat, the Cuttyhunk Cafe is a cherished destination for locals and visitors alike.
While the cafe is a grab-and-go venue, they have a table right out front to enjoy our treats. They open bright and early at 5am.
Check out their facebook for additional details and the latest updates
Cuttyhunk Fishing Club Breakfast
The only full-service breakfast option with one of the best views on Cuttyhunk
Indulge in the authentic charm of Cuttyhunk Island with a delightful breakfast experience at the Cuttyhunk Fishing Club. They are the only full-service breakfast option and serve delicious breakfast every day of the week. There can be a wait during busy times but there’s a beautiful lawn to kill time with breathtaking views.
Location: On Cemetery Road, on the way to the West End
Hours: Open every day for breakfast from 8-11am in July & August
Cuttyhunk Picnic Company
Curated charcuterie and dessert boxes to enjoy anywhere on the island
The Cuttyhunk Picnic Company offers delicious charcuterie and dessert boxes for you to enjoy anywhere you choose. They are the perfect companion to your beach day, happy hour at the dock or afternoon snack on your boat. You can call/text (508.687-0682) or email (cuttyhunkpicnicco@gmail.com) them to place your order or submit a form on their website.
Cuttyhunk Raw Bar
Cuttyhunk Shellfish Farms has a variety of dining options including the Raw Bar and Scuttlebutt Grille
They offer a delightful selection of locally sourced shellfish, including oysters and clams, prepared with a focus on freshness and quality. Set against the backdrop of Cuttyhunk Island, the raw bar is a must-visit for those seeking a genuine taste of the sea’s bounty.
Raw Bar
You can find the Raw Bar at the fishing dock. It’s a grab-and-go storefront but there are plenty of seating options nearby
Open Memorial Day through Columbus Day,
11:30-1:30, 3:30-7pmish
The Harbor Raw Bar
They will deliver any item on our menu right to your boat and service the pond, harbor, and marina. Just call them on VHF Channel 72 or stop by the shack at the Fisherman’s Dock.
Scuttlebutt Grille
Offers full Lobster Dinners at their unique outdoor event space throughout the seasons. Check their facebook for the latest information
Ice Cream Shop
A sweet treat located at the fishing dock
Located at the fishing dock, the Ice Cream Shop offers a rotating menu of ice cream flavors throughout the summer season. They also have some additional desserts and ice available for purchase. Make sure you stop by and see what they have available during your trip!
They only accept cash so make sure you have some on hand!
Island Market Sandwiches
Made-to-order sandwiches in the center of town
In addition to fresh produce and grocery staples, the Island Market offers made-to-order sandwiches from their small deli counter.
Lobster Shack
A great option take-out food (more than just seafood) by the fishing dock
The Lobster Shack is located in the parking lot of the fishing dock next to the ice cream shop. They have a variety of delicious food including lobster dinner and lobster rolls. You can find them open seasonally for lunch and dinner. Food is served take-out-style but they have some great seating options close by. The Lobster shack is run by the same owners of the Cuttyhunk Cafe and share the same social media accounts.
Soprano’s Pizza
One of the only sit-down restaurants on Cuttyhunk serving delicious pizza in a back-yard setting
Soprano’s Pizza on Cuttyhunk Island is a culinary gem that marries the rustic charm of gourmet brick oven pizza with the allure of seafood specials, all set against the backdrop of a picturesque outdoor venue. With a nod to the island’s maritime heritage, Soprano’s presents a menu that embodies the spirit of Cuttyhunk, where flavors converge in delightful harmony. From a classic pepperoni to their delectable seafood-infused pies, every bite resonates with the island’s essence. Soprano’s Pizza isn’t just a meal; it’s an invitation to savor the tastes, sights, and community warmth that Cuttyhunk Island has to offer
They open seasonally typically between June and August.
